Chambers Ireland perspective on Budget 2024
There was little that will have surprised Chambers Ireland’s members in today’s (10/10/2023) budget announcements, with much of the content well flagged in advance. Our budget priorities for 2024 were focused on Housing and Infrastructure, and our expectations regarding the increased funding for both of these areas were met.
Should the fund for smaller businesses act through Commercial Rates, this rebate this would be extremely welcome. The businesses that were most affected by Covid-19 and last month’s increase in VAT rates will also be those most affected by energy costs, the increase in minimum wages, the additional leave entitlements that are arising in January and the introduction of autoenrollment pensions in 2024, using this mechanism to get support to those businesses will be efficient and effective.
However, on balance, Budget24 is likely to be inflationary and the reduction in personal taxes are likely to have a neutral to negative affect the real incomes of lower-income households over the course of 2024, they will raise business costs, while also reducing government income.
Speaking after Ministers McGrath’s and Donohoe’s speeches, Chambers Ireland’s Chief Executive, Ian Talbot, said:
€250m Fund for small businesses:
“Today’s budget is clearly a budget that has households and families as its focus. On the business side, Chambers Ireland welcomes this extra support for smaller businesses as this will likely target many of the businesses most affected by the increases in regulatory burdens that are expected in 2024. Should this be delivered through a Commercial Rates rebated, this would be ideal as it would be a simple mechanism for the delivery of supports which was demonstrated to be very effective during the Covid Crisis.
Infrastructure:
“Chambers Ireland strongly supports the increased funding for infrastructure and transport infrastructure in particular. This increased funding, financed through the excess receipts Corporation Tax receipts, is vital to support the enhanced National Development Plan delivery. Our population is growing because of the opportunities which are available here in Ireland.
“However, the greatest constraint on our economy is the lack of Infrastructure and Housing. These gaps are increasing costs and make it harder for businesses to attract and retain staff. Increasing the capacity of our economy through improving infrastructure is likely to see far greater returns on investment than investing our excess Corporation Taxes in the global economy.
Housing:
“The increased funding for retrofitting is welcome, and the €7 Billion in funding for the Department of Housing and strongly support the creation of projects where Local Authorities directly contract for the building of social housing as that will prevent them distorting the local housing market.
Personal Taxes and Inflation:
“Many of the personal tax changes that are to be implemented as part of Budget24 are inflationary. Inflation is a tax, so policies which reduce taxes for one part of society will see the inflation related costs distributed across the rest of the economy. While it is unclear at this stage where these inflationary costs will fall, it is likely that it will be businesses and lower waged workers that will carry the greatest load.
Savings Funds:
“The new savings funds are welcome, but their focus is incorrect. The Future Ireland fund seems to be another ‘national pension fund’ and is likely to be used in a similar way should the economic headwinds move against Ireland. Meanwhile, the ‘Infrastructure, Climate and Nature’ Fund is underpowered given the ambition of the National Development Plan, and the need to expand it in response to the faster than expected growth in population. Sequestering monies that could otherwise fuel inflation if they were spent too quickly otherwise is good governance, but more may could have been done to strengthen these funds in this budget.
Tax Exemptions:
“We welcome the news that there will be a sub-group on the simplification of use of tax exemptions as there is a sense within the business community that the complexity of using these reliefs is a demand control measure. The Government needs to adhere more closely to the EUs ‘Think Small First’ principles when implementing these schemes.
“The review and roll out of entrepreneur reliefs related to Angel investors, EIIS, KEEP etc. is welcome but changes in these schemes have typically been incremental which has tended to limit the impact on their uptake.
“Ireland is a country that does not compare well against peer nations when it comes to starting and scaling up businesses and there is a huge opportunity cost that is associated with this, a fact that is demonstrated by the difficulties the Irish Stock Exchange is facing.
“A pro-growth perspective for companies that are operating within the Irish domestic economy is vital for our long-term sustainability, and to compensate for our national over-reliance on the Corporation Tax receipts that originate from a small number of firms.”
ENDS
For more information:
Shane Conneely, Director of Policy and Communications, 086 3244 940 or email shane.conneely@chambers.ie
About Chambers Ireland:
Chambers Ireland is the voice of business throughout Ireland, with 40 member chambers across every major city, town and region of the island. Aligning our strategic priorities with the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals, our aim is to make places better to live, work and do business.